FEATURE ARTICLE, OCTOBER 2004
TALKING MONEY
Lending companies discuss current trends and predictions
for financing in the Northeast.
Dawn Pick Benson
Northeast Real Estate Business recently spoke with leading
lenders across the Northeast to get their take on current
market conditions, as well as their predictions for lending
in 2005. The consensus is that the New York City market is
performing the best overall. While multifamily and retail
properties are performing exceptionally well, the suburban
office market is lagging. Many lenders are also reporting
that their lending volume is up significantly this year over
last year, and most predict that the overall lending environment
will continue to be very competitive.
Northeast Markets
Many markets are doing well in the Northeast, but according
to lenders, New York City is outpacing them all. Metropolitan
New York City is the strongest market at present, both in
Manhattan and in the New York/New Jersey/Connecticut suburbs,
says Dan Guenther, director of portfolio risk with MetLife
Real Estate Investments. Philadelphia is also benefiting
from strength in the life sciences sector of the economy,
he says. Hartford and Providence are growing slowly; Metropolitan
Boston is starting to stabilize from the dot-com/telecom slump,
but Guenther says mergers in the financial services sector
may delay an economic rebound.
The markets that I work in New York, New Jersey
and Pennsylvania are all hot, says Gary Cohen,
regional vice president with PW Funding Inc. With low
interest rates and institutional investors still aggressive
on real estate, they are bidding up the prices for assets.
The market for acquiring and financing properties net
leased to credit tenants regardless of property type
is strong throughout the country, including the Northeast,
says William Pollert, president of Capital Lease Funding Inc.
While residential and retail are the most active sectors in
the Northeast, most lenders say the suburban office market
is not faring as well. Retail and apartments in the
Northeast are hot, says Marilyn Mawn, associate director
with Bear, Stearns & Co. New York office is particularly
strong right now as well. But suburban office outside of the
New York metro area is struggling.
John Edwards, director with Arbor Commercial Mortgage, agrees.
He says that major markets in the Northeast are seeing significant
condo activity, but the office markets continue to struggle.
New York City remains very active, especially in the
residential sector, says Patrick Crandall, vice president
and regional manager at Fremont Investment & Loan. There
have been numerous office acquisitions in Manhattan over the
past 18 months, and the fundamentals for the office sector
continue to improve.
According to Crandall, Boston has also been very active on
the residential side, but the office market there continues
to languish. Suburban office in most of the Northeast
is still somewhat soft, says Crandall.
Guenther also says the apartment sector has performed exceptionally
well in the Northeast, with upscale retail centers a close
second. Office markets are also showing signs of improvement,
as is the warehouse sector in New Jersey, he says.
Scott Zucker, managing director and head of origination with
CDC Mortgage Capital Inc., says that anchored retail in in-fill
urban locations is doing well.
We like urban retail, especially in underserved areas,
says Chuck Rosenzweig, managing director with RBS Greenwich
Capital. He adds that the company has also done well with
lending on office buildings in Manhattan and in Fairfield
County, Connecticut.
The hotel market has been improving in Manhattan, says Crandall,
and industrial remains steady. However, he says limited-service
hotels in secondary markets are lagging.
Current Trends and Future Predictions
When asked how current lending compares with lending in 2003,
Mawn says demand is much heavier now. Bear Stearns
volume is up significantly from 2003, she says. Andrew
Fawer, managing director with CIBC World Markets, agrees:
We had a record year in 2003, only to be broken in 2004.
Kennedy Funding has also seen an increase in volume compared
to 2003. And we see no reason this should not continue
into next year, says Jeffrey Wolfer, president of Kennedy
Funding.
Lending volumes and competition remain at high levels
this year, says Guenther. Most lenders appear
to still be underwriting prudently. However, he says
that high property valuations pose additional risk for lenders
in 2004.
Crandall says there continues to be a significant amount of
capital available in the marketplace, and lenders are increasingly
aggressive to win quality projects with quality sponsors.
The recent increase in interest rates doesnt seem
to have slowed the pace of investment sales or development
in active markets, he says.
There has definitely been more competition this year
as some new lenders have entered the market, says Rosenzweig.
He says this has led to more capital, and borrowers have benefited
as loan spreads have come down due to the increased competition.
Zucker also says the competitive lending environment is leading
to tighter spreads and easier underwriting standards than
in 2003.
The demand for permanent credit tenant lease (CTL) financing
is somewhat stronger than in 2003 as borrowers seek to lock
in todays low rates, long-term, before rates begin to
move up, says Pollert.
In regards to the year ahead, many believe the lending environment
will continue to be extremely competitive. If interest
rates move up and most people think they will
the lending environment will become even more competitive,
says Cohen. There will be less trading of properties
and less refinancing, so lenders will be doing all they can
to get business.
We feel there will continue to be an abundance of capital,
and the environment will continue to be competitive,
says Mawn. Talk of the Fed increasing rates continues
to motivate property owners.
Guenther also believes that competition will remain intense.
Cap rates are likely to stabilize soon and to start
trending upward modestly in 2005 as interest rates rise,
he says.
As rates rise in 2004 and 2005, Pollert says there will be
increasing pressure for borrowers who are on floating-rate
mini-perms to lock in permanent financing.
I think interest rates will continue to rise at a moderate
pace and the environment will remain highly competitive as
fundamentals continue to improve along with the overall economy,
says Crandall.
While interest rates will affect the lending environment,
changes in underwriting are also expected to affect the competition
amongst lenders. In our sector of the business, we are
less affected by interest rate fluctuation than by tightening
of credit underwriting by the banks and other more traditional
lenders, according to Wolfer of Kennedy Funding. He
says, People who utilize Kennedy Funding do so not for
pricing, but for the ability to get the deal done when no
one else can, because certain aspects of the deal may not
be bankable, or the need for speed. Not many companies
can close a $5 million, $10 million, or $20 million dollar
loan in a week or two.
Looking to the future of lending in the Northeast, lenders
have various predictions. I think 2005 will see a slowdown
in the financing business, says Cohen, but hopefully
in 2006 and beyond, we will see a pick-up because a lot of
the business done in the mid- to late- 1990s will start coming
up for refinance.
Institutional lenders will continue to seek out opportunities
in major metropolitan areas in the Northeast as the long-term
economic outlook is bright for this university-laden region
in an increasingly global economy, says Guenther. He
predicts that smaller metro areas will struggle, however,
as the manufacturing sector continues to contract.
CDC Mortgage Capital
Inc.
Headquarters: New York
Active: Nationwide
Types of loans provided: Fixed- and floating-rate mortgage
loans, mezzanine and various forms of other financing
for transactions in excess of $5 million.
Recent Transaction: CDC Mortgage Capital provided $80
million in floating-rate financing for Park 80 West Plaza
I and II, which is a 489,994-square-foot, two-building,
Class A office complex located in Saddle Brook, New Jersey.
The complex is adjacent to the Saddle Brook Marriott Hotel
near Interstate 80 and the Garden State Parkway.
The deal was challenging because of the borrowers
desire to obtain a fully leveraged loan on a property
located in a market experiencing slow leasing momentum
with substantial available space. We handled this by structuring
the financing as a combination of both a mortgage loan
and a mezzanine loan, which we closed as a principal.
This enabled the borrower to obtain the leverage it was
seeking from a single source without having to negotiate
with multiple lenders. CDCs loan was structured
with appropriate leasing reserves to address the market
issues.
We were chosen to service the loan because of our reputation
for closing loans on a timely basis on the agreed-upon
terms. This was enhanced by our practice of lending as
a principal so the borrower was not at risk of other lenders
delaying the process or trying to change the terms of
the deal.
Scott Zucker, Managing Director, Head of
Origination
|
Capital Lease
Funding, Inc.
Headquarters: New York
Active: Capital Lease Funding (CapLease) is a publicly
traded net lease REIT focused on commercial real estate
assets that are net leased to high credit quality corporate,
governmental and not-for-profit tenants.
Types of loans provided: CapLease offers self-amortizing,
long-term credit tenant lease (CTL) loans with debt service
coverage as low as 1.0; balloon balance credit
tenant lease financing; high-leverage, 10-year CTL debt
structures; rate locks and forward take-outs; property
acquisitions and equity partnerships; and Joint Venture
Development Programs that provide equity to cover pre-development
costs and meet the equity requirements of the construction
lender.
Recent Transaction: CapLease structured and closed a $22.8
million loan for the construction of a 100,000-square-foot
medical research building in Farmington, Connecticut,
which is leased to the University of Connecticut. Construction
is expected to be complete in early 2005.
The transaction had several unique aspects. In addition
to requiring the loan to be funded within a tight timeframe,
the borrower was seeking to obtain construction financing
while simultaneously locking in permanent financing at
todays historically low interest rates. Other issues
included the lack of a special purpose entity, sovereign
immunity, appropriations risk and use restrictions.
CapLease was able to structure a permanent fixed-rate
credit tenant lease loan that served as both a construction
loan and permanent financing. The full amount of the permanent
loan was funded pre-construction and the borrower was
able to lock in todays low rates. The loan closed
within weeks of application.
William R. Pollert, President
|
Kennedy Funding,
Inc.
Headquarters: Hackensack, New Jersey
Active: Nationwide
Types of loans provided: We provide asset-based loans,
primarily real estate financing. We specialize in hard-to-do
deals, including bankruptcy, foreclosure scenarios, land
loans and development loans. We also are known for closing
very quickly, sometimes in as little as a week.
Popular loan products: There is a lot of demand for land
development loans, particularly for the mid-level developers
and projects. We are also seeing a lot of redevelopment
type loans, i.e. acquisition and positioning for redevelopment.
Recent Transaction: We have just closed an $18.5 million
deal on a property on the Las Vegas strip. Currently a
closed motel, the property is adjacent to the airport
and therefore has some height restriction uncertainty
that is an issue impacting what may be built there. Although
we feel we are secured even if a height restriction is
in place, in the event the developer gets a variance,
the property becomes much more valuable. In addition,
we closed that loan in 2 weeks time, something that
gives us an edge over most of our competition.
Jeffrey Wolfer, President
|
Arbor Commercial
Mortgage, LLC
Headquarters: Uniondale, New York
Active: Nationwide.
Types of loans provided: For all income producing properties,
Arbor provides permanent loans through FNMA, FHA and Conduit
execution; the company also provides bridge, mezzanine,
preferred equity, and note acquisitions through Arbor
Realty Trust.
Recent Transaction: New Brunswick Apartments is a 206-unit
apartment complex located in New Brunswick, New Jersey.
Arbor provided a $14.94 million Bond Credit Enhancement
through Fannie Mae. The property has a 100 percent Project
Based Housing Assistance Payments Contract (HAP). This
transaction required that we wrap the individual sources
of equity to facilitate the extensive renovation, while
maintaining the existing occupancy. Arbor crafted the
bond credit enhancement that included tax credits, a de-coupling
of the Interest Reduction Payment (IRP), and underwriting
with the new HAP contract rents. (An IRP is a subsidy
to reduce the effective mortgage interest rate paid by
the project. IRP is part of a HUD 236 mortgage and, in
the event the borrower elects to extinguish the HUD 236
mortgage through a refinance, the borrower can elect to
(1) pay off the debt and IRP or (2) pay off the debt and
maintain the IRP. In the second scenario, we wrap the
IRP into the new mortgage as is the case with New Brunswick
Apartments.)
Arbor handled the challenge through a collaborative effort
by both the borrower and Arbors underwriting and
legal team. We were chosen to service the loan because
of our flexibility to offer bridge financing to satisfy
the seller, should it take longer to secure the required
legal documentation in order to secure the IRP.
John Edwards, Director
|
Fremont Investment
& Loan
Headquarters: Anaheim, California
Active: Nationwide.
Types of loans provided: We provide short-term, floating-rate,
bridge loans and construction loans of $10 million and
up on a non- or limited recourse basis. Our loans typically
involve properties in which there is some opportunity
for value creation or ground-up construction. We will
also roll our bridge and construction loans into a mini-perm
if it makes sense for the business plan.
Recent Transaction: Fremont provided $111.3 million in
acquisition and construction financing for an office building
with planned conversion to mixed-use. The property is
located at 15 Broad Street in New York City. Situated
directly across from the New York Stock Exchange, the
asset is a New York City landmark and the original headquarters
of J.P. Morgan. The 1 million-square-foot property comprises
three separate buildings: 15 Broad Street, 23 Wall Street,
and 35 Wall Street.
Originally, Fremont provided a $75 million acquisition
loan to this repeat borrower prior to having all plans
and permits in place. We then rolled that loan into a
construction loan once all the approvals were obtained.
Due to the size of the construction loan, Fremont required
a participating lender to close the deal. We successfully
participated the transaction prior to closing and will
act as lead lender throughout the life of the deal.
The deal was challenging because the borrower needed to
acquire the asset prior to having solid plans in place
for the repositioning of the property. This was Fremonts
third deal with this borrower and Fremont is confident
in the borrowers ability to complete the plans,
obtain the approvals, and build a quality product that
will meet the demands of the marketplace.
Patrick Crandall, Vice President and Regional
Manager
|
MetLife Real
Estate Investments
Headquarters: Morristown, New Jersey
Active: MetLife makes commercial mortgage loans throughout
North America and in Europe. Our New Jersey regional office
covers the Northeast, from Pennsylvania through Maine.
Types of loans provided: MetLife makes conventional commercial
mortgage investments (fixed-rate and floating-rate, short-term
and long-term). The company also provides structured financing
and invests on an equity basis in joint ventures.
Popular loan products: Short-term, floating-rate loans
are very popular, as are long-term, fixed-rate loans.
Recent Transaction: Greenwich Office Park, which includes
350,000 square feet of office space in seven buildings,
is located at 51 Weaver Street in Greenwich, Connecticut.
This deal is significant because it is a very well-leased,
high-quality, renovated office park with a local tenant
roster in a high vacancy suburban market. We analyzed
local demand closely as part of the underwriting and stress
testing of future loan performance. Our company was chosen
over other companies to service the loan because we negotiated
competitive terms for the financing following our rigorous
analysis of the property and submarket.
Dan Guenther, Director of Portfolio Risk
|
CIBC World Markets
Headquarters: New York
Active: Nationwide.
Types of loans provided: Construction, bridge, redevelopment,
permanent, and mezzanine loans.
Popular loan products: Our clients have been building
ground up, redeveloping properties, or wishing to lock
in low, long-term rates. We have been very successful
in providing one-stop shopping by offering
the construction or bridge financing, then permanent financing.
Clients can take advantage of additional capital in the
form of mezzanine debt. We have been flexible on the term
of permanent financing: 5- to 20- year financing is available.
Recent Transaction: CIBC recently closed a loan on State
House Square, an 855,000-square-foot Class A office building
located in Hartford, Connecticut. Acquisition financing
of $52 million made the deal challenging. It needed to
close in time for purchase, and appropriate reserves were
needed to be structured for lease rollover. CIBC was able
to work quickly with the borrower to close the deal, while
structuring appropriate reserves for tenant rollover occurring
in the next few years.
Andrew S. Fawer, Managing Director
|
Headquarters: New York
Active: Nationwide.
Types of loans provided: Mostly fixed-rate loans, as well
as some floating-rate debt and construction loans
Popular loan products: Everything. With interest rates
at very low levels, clients needs vary, but money
is cheap so business is hot and competitive. I have done
a lot of long-term, self-amortizing deals.
Recent Transaction: A portfolio of 33 apartment properties,
totaling approximately $224 million. The properties were
all located in New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania.
The deal was challenging because the borrower had expectations
that we had to meet regarding no reserves, and the property
conditions varied.
PW Funding handled the challenge with a team of 12 to
15 people from various offices around the country who
all worked together to get the business done. Our company
was chosen to service the loan because we have a long-term
relationship with the borrower and they trusted us. Many
of our borrowers come back to us with their financing
needs, time and time again.
Gary Cohen, Regional Vice President
|
Bear, Stearns
& Co.
Headquarters: New York
Active: Nationwide
Types of loans provided: Fixed- and floating-rate loans
for the entire debt stack on income producing properties.
Popular loan products: Floating-rate loans and high leverage
fixed-rate deals.
Recent Transaction: Bear Stearns financed a property in
Chester County, Pennsylvania, that contains a regional
mall, neighborhood shopping center, and a stand-alone
theater. The total collateral for the loan consists of
803,527 square feet, and it is located on 63.11 acres.
The regional mall consists of 696,601 square feet, certain
out parcels consist of 85,359 square feet, and the theater
consists of 21,466 square feet. The property is currently
96.6 percent leased to approximately 90 tenants.
The deal was challenging because the loan had significant
moving parts. Bear Stearns loaned the borrower $94 million,
allowing them 60 days to secure an equity partner and
then pay the loan down to $77 million. Additionally, one
of the anchors was still under construction at closing
and another was closing and being replaced by Kohls.
Bear Stearns was chosen over the competition because of
our ability to close within 3 weeks and creatively structure
the loan to meet the borrowers needs.
Marilyn Mawn, Associate Director
|
RBS Greenwich
Capital
Headquarters: Greenwich, Connecticut
Active: Nationwide
Types of loans provided: Fixed- and floating-rate mortgages
as well as mezzanine and preferred equity financing. Fixed-rate
loans range from $5 million to more than $500 million
and floating-rate loans range from $20 million to more
than $500 million.
Recent Transaction: Our largest loan in the region over
the past year was 111 Eighth Avenue in New York City.
We provided $500 million of a first mortgage loan as part
of recapitalization of 111 Eighth Avenue. The property
is a 2.9 million-square-foot office building located in
the Chelsea submarket of Manhattan and occupies an entire
city block between Eighth and Ninth avenues and 15th and
16th streets.
Approximately 30 percent of the building was leased to
telecom tenants and the building was not a traditional
high-rise office building. We became very comfortable
with the real estate because large corporate users have
been attracted to 111 Eighth as their headquarters space.
The building is attractive to these companies because
of its large floorplates, high ceilings and large floor-to-ceiling
windows. As a telecom building, it is one of the most
connected buildings on the East Coast; it is home
to many of the worlds leading telecom providers.
Our company was chosen to service the loan because we
have done previous lending with the sponsorship and they
were extremely focused on reliability and certainty of
closing. Our strong balance sheet was important to principal
a $500 million loan.
Chuck Rosenzweig, Managing Director
|
©2004 France Publications, Inc. Duplication
or reproduction of this article not permitted without authorization
from France Publications, Inc. For information on reprints
of this article contact Barbara
Sherer at (630) 554-6054.
|